Little Italy Restaurant

Food is always great. Price is always right. Best spot in Evansville!

Each of two times we've been, we've picked up a single 3- 4 topping pizza from the drive-through window. And both times we were charged an 8.42% 'Convenience Fee' that was noted on their website when the order were completed by credit card. There was no option to pay for the order with cash to avoid a convenience fee so I'm assuming this fee applies to all carry out orders. I should note that the pizza was in a standard cardboard pizza box with was no aluminum foil, parchment paper, addition cardboard, a plastic crush protector, or anything else extra. No cheese, red pepper flakes, carry out plasticware, or napkins were included or needed. The fee seems very excessive in comparison to other similar restaurants in the Evansville area. Most convenience fees in cap out at around 3-4 percent. Some have no fees at all. For instance Pangea on GRR, The Twisted Tomato on St George, and Rounder 2 in Daylight charge no additional fees. 10-9-26 EDIT: added photo which shows the restaurant PREFERS Menufy

What a terrible experience honestly this is a place you would see on kitchen nightmares. I've been wanting to go here for years and finally get to take my wife on a date for her birthday and thought she would love this place cause she loves Italian food. Well where do I start got there at 7:10 it was packed ok, waited 15 minutes not a big deal. Got our table and some bread sticks alright they were good, still excited. Waitress gets out drinks after 10 minutes I got sweet tea, wife got pib. For the waitress to bring me coke instead redflag but it's alright clocks ticking just enjoying the moment. Finally got our order taken after a good wait. She didn't even write it down, another red flag. After about 30 to 40 minutes of waiting we notice everyone who came in after us gets their food first then after almost an hour of waiting for our food it comes, the fettuccine Alfredo was bland and over creamed and my spaghetti and meatballs was sub par, I had cold frozen meat balls so I said something they took it and put it in the microwave and brought it back out now I had Luke warm frozen meatballs needless to say it was a total let down and waste of time and money. Gordon ramsey would have been furious

I had the best chicken parm. It was great and the service was wonderful....

This is the best Italian food in Evansville! Our server Angela gave top quality hospitality. Will always recommend to everyone.

Best thing i have eaten in years 10/10.

Little Italy’s is being at home while getting 5-star food and friendliness.

The food is outstanding as well as the service. It is a small facility so noise can be an issue when the restaurant is filled. My experience was outstanding - I highly recommend the lasagna.

Food is excellent, atmosphere is nice, and despite clearly being busy and short-handed, the staff was working very hard to make up for it.

Restaurant. Restaurant.

We ordered catering for our staff lunch and everything was fantastic! The food is very well made, with quality ingredients, and the bread is so good. Carlos made sure we had plenty of food. We have ordered from Olive Garden in the past, but never again - Little Italy is now our go to Italian restaurant for lunch catering!