Rogues Harbor Inn 1830 LLC

Great atmosphere. Very nostalgic. Food was amazing. Always has been. Thank you.

The policy for cancellation is ridiculous. You have to cancel 14 days prior! If you need to cancel because of family issues you’re out of luck. They keep your entire stay! Please get with the times, The Embassy Suits isn’t that strict! Very disappointed ☹️

Had a lovely experience at the historic Rogue’s Harbor Inn! The staff was absolutely tremendous, the breakfast exactly what I needed and the room was clean and well kept. I forgot something very important to me and they even offered to ship it back to my apartment in providence which was just the cherry on top. Very much recommend to anyone looking for accommodations in Lansing/near Ithaca!

I was very pleasantly impressed with the atmosphere and quality of this inn. It’s conveniently close to Ithaca, but tucked away just up the lake. The rooms and building are elegantly and tastefully decorated, the furnishings are modern and well-maintained (especially for a historic building), the staff and Eileen are kind and accommodating, and it’s a great value for the price. I was especially impressed with how thoughtful and meticulous the experience was, both aesthetically and functionally. They carefully attend to the small details, whether in your unique room or serving you food in the dining atrium, and it makes a big difference in your experience. For anyone visiting the finger lakes, I’d expect coming to a place like the Rogues Harbor Inn will augment your experience in the serene countryside with its complementary refinement and sophisticated charm. And, it’s half the price of the more crowded competitors in Ithaca proper, but only a short (and pretty) drive away. I’ll be recommending it to friends and coming back sometime soon.

Very old building, which has its own charm. The building is old and crooked, with little (sound) insulation. Given its location on two busy roads with loud traffic, that is certainly necessary. The service was friendly, but the breakfast was mediocre. The entire breakfast room was filled with a thick cloud of greasy fumes. Considering the price, you would expect better.

We thoroughly enjoyed our four night stay with Eileen. The breakfast was fresh and delicious every day. The rooms and house are decorated beautifully, clean, comfortable, and spacious. Eileen and the staff are genuine and easy to chat with. I will definitely recommend Rogues to anyone going that way.

I loved the atmosphere and character of staying in a place that was built in 1830. The breakfast was above average and gave a homey feeling,

Stopped for food. Friendly, Clean and Fast. The food is good as well. Nice and pleasant experience.

We've stayed at Rogues Harbor many times and it's always great. The rooms are wonderfully appointed, the breakfasts delicious and the staff friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend.

Not an enjoyable visit. Food was barely adequate. Service OK. Noise level much too loud to have an enjoyable evening with my date. Will think twice next time and probably go somewhere else.