The Whately Inn

Very ,very disappointed ! We went there for Valentines day with 2 other couples, the menu was limited, the prices were obviously increased for that day, 2 of the featured items were sold out by 6:30. The service was absolutely appalling for a restaurant that you spend 600.00 for dinner before tip and our dinners were mediocre at best. It would take to long to elaborate on how bad it was on here but when I reached out to the owners/manager, (leaving a message with a woman) because I didn't want to really leave a bad review, I wanted to discussed where they should improve ext.. They never bothered to call me back !! I or the other 2 couples will never go there again.

Beautiful inside and out , great deals and meal was delicious. Went there for valentine's day with my wife. Seafood was tender, lobster was delicious and chicken parm was just right !! I highly recommend this restaurant

Reservations for 5:30pm, arrived at 5:20pm Friday evening. 2/13/26. Seated promptly, our server arrived, Nicolle and introduced herself. Very friendly and informative about menu etc. Our drinks served promptly, gave Nicolle our order, she informed us about what came with our order. Food arrived hot and very delicious. We could not have been happier with service and atmosphere. We will return.

Delicious as always. Had the beef wellington with duck mousse, and my wife had lobster casserole. Bothe had our favorite - au gratin potatos. Such a wonderful restaurant.

First, I would like to say that the Whately Inn is still my favorite restaurant. The meals have always been fantastic. From the fresh fruit cocktail and rolls, all the way to the delicious chocolate fudge pie and coffee you can't beat the Whately Inn. That being said, yesterday my girlfriend and I visited for Valentines day. We both ordered the Prime Rib. My Prime Rib had a large bone type of structure in it that significantly reduced the amount of meat in the meal. It is the first time that I have been disappointed in my entree. I will consider this a one off and continue to go to the Whately Inn on occasion. Rick Hayden

Had dinner with great friends. Been there a few times. Food is great. Very generous portions. We always split the bill down the middle between us. When my statement came in the mail I seen that my credit card was charged for both couples. I only signed one and the other couple signed the other which would not make it legal to charge me. Called and owner said he is sorry but he had 21000$ of credit card charges that day and it’s hard to keep track of. And if my card was charged twice it would have to of had an override. Obviously it was! He can’t take a hit for 118 ( apparently I should) dollars but if my friends were good enough friends they would give me my money back! Wow not very professional at all! I’ll let my credit card get it back thank you!!! Sorry not sure we will come back. Not the way I would have handled that. So very disappointed from such an establishment that is well known!! Check your credit card statements people. Who knows how many times this had happened!!!

The food here is superb! We come here regularly for special events and just because :). This time, we went for New Years. Dinner was excellent as usual, but we were seated in a corner that was serviced by a waitress that either was new or really didn't care. When the food came, it wasn't very warm (which is a huge change, it's always hot and right off the stove). It took longer than usual, which was fine because it was a busy holiday. Once delivered, the waitress didn't come back. No drink checks, no making sure that dinner was up to standard, if we needed anything etc. When she did come back, we were finished and our plates were mostly empty. Only then did she ask if we needed anything or drink refills. Well no. She came back with a container for my leftovers because it was "quicker than waiting for someone else to help us". I didn't realize that we needed another server, but ok. She gave us the dessert menu, looked in the mirror above us to check her hair, quickly took our order and didn't even wait for us to tell her that we wanted coffee with our dessert. We felt like the first part we waited a while, then once she remembered us, we were being rushed out. From what we could see, she only had 4 tables in our area, and all of us had been there the same length of time. We understand that for the Holiday she may have been additional help, but it didn't go very far in giving customers the welcoming feeling that is usually present. We will be back, and hopefully with a different server.