Shirley Brito
Jul 2026
★★★★★
We are staying at Super Paradise Hotel and noticed JackieO’ from our hotel. It looked beautiful from a distance, with an amazing location overlooking the sea, so we decided to have dinner there.
The restaurant is beautiful, the setting is stunning, and the atmosphere is lovely. However, when we arrived, we were surprised to see that such a large restaurant was almost completely empty. For the first hour, we were the only guests. Later, only one table of four arrived. By the end of the evening, we completely understood why.
I want to be fair: the service was excellent. The staff were kind, attentive, and professional.
Unfortunately, the food was a huge disappointment.
We ordered a Fiorentina steak and specifically asked for it medium cooked. The steak alone cost €250, a price we were happy to pay if the quality matched it. Instead, it arrived heavily overcooked and burnt on the outside. It was nowhere near medium.
As soon as it arrived, we told the staff that the cooking was not what we had ordered. They acknowledged our comment, but they never offered to take it back and prepare another steak cooked correctly. Instead, they simply left it on the table.
My husband was very hungry, so he tried to eat it anyway. He had to cut away the darkest burnt parts and only ate some of the meat because he was hungry. I, on the other hand, simply couldn’t eat it. It was too overcooked and unpleasant. You can clearly see the condition of the steak in the photos.
At the end of the meal, instead of replacing the steak or taking responsibility for the mistake, they brought us a complimentary dessert. While we appreciate the gesture, that was not the solution. We didn’t want a free dessert—we wanted the €250 steak we ordered to be cooked correctly. A complimentary dessert does not make up for serving an expensive main course that was prepared incorrectly.
Our bill was around €500, and we left extremely disappointed. When you spend that kind of money on dinner, especially while on vacation, you expect to enjoy a great meal. Instead, we left hungry and frustrated.
It is a real shame because the location is spectacular and the service is genuinely very good. But the quality of the food simply doesn’t justify the prices. In the end, it became obvious why such a beautiful restaurant, in such an incredible location, was almost empty on a summer evening in Mykonos.
Sadly, I cannot recommend this restaurant. There are many places in Mykonos where you can spend the same money and actually enjoy an excellent meal.😡🤦🏼♀️👎👎👎👎👎👎