The Whitney

Food was average at best. The centerpiece of the brunch was prime rib which was overcooked. All brunch items were served to us by staff with portions that didn't match the price. A dip of this, a dab of that... sure you can go back but still. ONE THIRD of one slice of ham, a piece of salmon not bigger than my thumb (no exaggeration), lobster Mac, but couldn't taste any lobster. Carrot slices were three at a time. Just offensive for the price and not tasty unfortunately. I've heard so much about this place over the years that it was a bucket list destination for me. The old mansion is interesting and the waiter tried hard, but the food and the food servers were sorely lacking.

Watch your bill - predatory gratuity practices. My wife and I used to love The Whitney, which makes this more disappointing. As a matter of fact, we got married here. But we recently had a very distasteful experience. We are a party of TWO and they included an automatic gratuity on our check. Fine, whatever, but then they still leave the tip line blank at the bottom like you're supposed to tip again on top of it. It's designed to trick you into double-tipping. We caught it after accidentally falling into the double tipping trap and management (Mark Bozo) acknowledged it and said "I will get this and get you refunded asap." We were polite and thanked him because we genuinely liked the place. We were never refunded. I hope the Whitney management considers making some changes to billing practices so this doesn't happen to anyone else. If you go, read your bill line by line. For a party of 2, there should not be an auto-gratuity, and there definitely shouldn't be an extra tip line on top of it to trick you to double tip. Certainly, managers should deliver on their promise to correct issues.

The combination of a unique setting, thoughtful service, and flavorful dishes made this a memorable dining experience. The space itself has a beautiful design and creates a great ambiance from the moment you arrive. The food was well prepared, filling, and exceeded expectations, while the seasonal tea added a creative touch to the meal. Every element came together nicely, from the welcoming staff to the impressive surroundings. A wonderful spot for a relaxed and enjoyable visit.

The beef Wellington and the carrot cake are excellent!

My family & I went to The Whitney last night & had an amazing time. Everyone who ordered wine was happy with what they got. The lobster bisque is a so freaking good, not salty at all. Everyone in our party enjoyed it, even those who are not big fans of lobster. The calamari & its sauce were perfect too. The seafood saute was a tad bit too salty for us. But the halibut with blackened shrimp was perfect, the mushroom risotto was delightful, and the Cajun cream sauce was a perfect accompaniment. The beef wellington was very filling & very delicious, according to the birthday girl. After dinner, we explored the many rooms, admired the stained glass, & discovered the ghost bar on the 3rd floor. My party & I had a wonderful time & I look fwd to going back

Can’t believe they let someone with Birkenstocks in the front door of this place. Absolutely disgusting 🤢. 1 Star

We had a delightful afternoon tea here recently. The mansion is an amazing place in its own right, with its tapestries, stained glass windows and carved wood architecture, and an ENORMOUS STAIRCASE leading upstairs (there's a small antique elevator too, where, if you take it, you'll never feel alone😉. There are numerous private dining rooms in the 3-story house-turned-restaurant, where you can dine like royalty on the establishment's various items, none of which are not 'just plain old food' by any means. Ive experienced afternoon tea at many fine places, but truthfully, The Whitney has some of the best recipes that I've ever tasted. Thank You, Whitney, for a job well done!

Shar was a great waiter. Excellent service.

An unforgettable experience from start to finish! We chose The Whitney for my wife’s birthday dinner, and I can honestly say it was one of the best dining experiences we’ve ever had. From the moment we walked through the doors, we were welcomed with genuine hospitality and made to feel like valued guests. Every detail—from the beautiful atmosphere to the outstanding service—made the evening feel special. A huge thank you to Regan, who was absolutely incredible. She was knowledgeable, attentive, personable, and took the time to explain the menu and answer every question we had. Her service alone deserves five stars. Now, the food… WOW. The Whitney Brick Chicken was simply phenomenal. Perfectly seasoned, incredibly tender, unbelievably juicy, and cooked to perfection. Without question, one of the best chicken dishes I’ve ever had. An easy 10/10. If you’re celebrating a birthday, anniversary, date night, or simply want an unforgettable dining experience, do yourself a favor and make a reservation at The Whitney. It completely lived up to its reputation and exceeded every expectation. We can’t wait to come back!