Best Gay Heritage in Fire Island

2 venues found

Fire Island | Gay Bars & Clubs (5) Gay Beaches (2) Cruising Areas (1) Gay-Friendly Hotels (11) Gay-Friendly Restaurants (1) LGBTQ+ Organizations (3) Gay Heritage (2) | Map

Refine by amenities, crowd, features

Gay Heritage 2.8 (8)

Carrington House

Gay Heritage

The c.1912 beach house where Truman Capote worked on Breakfast at Tiffany's, recognised for its LGBTQ associations within Fire Island National Seashore.

Gay

Verified by GayOut Sep 2026

Gay Heritage 4.6 (14)

Cherry Grove Community House & Theatre

Gay Heritage

Community House on Bayview Walk, home since 1948 of the Arts Project of Cherry Grove, the oldest continuously running LGBTQ theatre in the US.

Gay

Verified by GayOut Sep 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Best Gay Heritage in Fire Island

Carrington House

Cherry Grove Community House & Theatre

Report a correction

Stay in the Loop

Install GayOut