GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at Shirley Motel
Check availability and book your room.
Gay Hotels
LGBTQ+ Friendly
Shirley Motel
Google
(174) 3.1
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
What reviewers say
Visitors generally find the Shirley Motel to be clean, cared for, and a good value with friendly people. However, there are complaints about inconsistent and high pricing, with one reviewer even calling the establishment "cockroach infested" and another stating they were charged different rates depending on who they dealt with.
62
/ 100
GayOut Score
G3.1
Compare prices for Shirley Motel
Real prices · Free cancellation · Best gay-friendly stays
Hotels near Shirley Motel
via Stay22Hotels near Shirley Motel
Loading map…
About this place Shirley Motel
Shirley Motel is a basic roadside motel at 681 Montauk Highway in Shirley, on Long Island's South Shore in Suffolk County. Rooms are plain, with microwaves and minifridges, and Wi-Fi and parking are free. The Google rating is a weak 3.1 from about 170 reviews, so read recent reviews before booking. It is a mainstream motel listed as gay-friendly, not a gay venue.
Its main use is as a cheap overnight stop on the way out east. Fire Island's Smith Point beach is nearby, while the ferries to the gay communities of Cherry Grove and the Pines leave from Sayville, about 20 minutes west.
Features
Gay-friendly (straight venue)
Card payments accepted
Walk-ins welcome
Reservation required
WiFi
Year-round
Gay-friendly (straight venue)
Air conditioning
Insider Tips
Community Reviews
Write a ReviewGoogle Reviews
Verified by Google3.1
★★★★★
174 reviews
Based on 174 Google reviews.
Michael Como
Jun 2026
★★★★★
Ok
jermaine lewis
Apr 2026
★★★★★
I’ve been staying there recently and basically… the husband and wife are charging two different rates for each stay. The husband will charge you $120, while the wife will charge you $140. Hope you get the husband and not the wife… she doesn’t seem to pleasant
Cibele Gonçalves
Feb 2026
★★★★★
lovevine Freeman
Jan 2026
★★★★★
Excellent
Aj H
Nov 2025
★★★★★
It serves its purpose
Sal Verdi
Aug 2025
★★★★★
Clean rooms
Kurtuluş Demir
Jul 2025
★★★★★
Write a Review
20 reviews so far — add yours
Suggest an Edit — Shirley Motel
Last updated on 6 November 2026