Shirley Motel Hotels in Yaphank – GayOut Guide
GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at Shirley Motel
Check availability and book your room.
Book a Room Now
Gay Hotels LGBTQ+ Friendly

Shirley Motel

Google (174) 3.1
What reviewers say

Visitors generally find the Shirley Motel to be clean, cared for, and a good value with friendly people. However, there are complaints about inconsistent and high pricing, with one reviewer even calling the establishment "cockroach infested" and another stating they were charged different rates depending on who they dealt with.

62
/ 100
GayOut Score
G3.1
✅ Link copied!
Address
681 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967, USA
📞
Phone
(631) 281-9418
🟢
Be the first to check in
Real-time community presence
No live tips yet — share what's happening here right now.

Hotels near Shirley Motel

via Stay22
Hotels near Shirley Motel
Loading map…

About this place Shirley Motel

Welcome to Shirley Motel, an inclusive and welcoming lodging option located in Yaphank, New York. While not exclusively a gay venue, this motel is recognized for its LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere, making it a comfortable choice for travelers of all backgrounds. Situated conveniently on Montauk Highway, Shirley Motel provides a straightforward and accessible base for exploring the surrounding areas. Guests can expect a no-frills yet functional accommodation experience. The rooms are equipped with essential amenities such as microwaves and minifridges, perfect for preparing light meals or storing snacks and beverages. Complimentary Wi-Fi is available throughout the property, ensuring you can stay connected during your visit, and free parking adds to the convenience for those traveling by car. The motel's basic yet reliable offerings aim to provide a comfortable and hassle-free stay, allowing you to focus on enjoying your trip to Yaphank and beyond. Shirley Motel is a practical and friendly choice for those seeking a pleasant and inclusive place to rest while discovering Long Island.

Insider Tips

No tips yet — be the first to share a local secret!

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
3.1
174 reviews

Based on 174 Google reviews.

Michael Como
Michael Como Jun 2026

Ok

jermaine lewis
jermaine lewis Apr 2026

I’ve been staying there recently and basically… the husband and wife are charging two different rates for each stay. The husband will charge you $120, while the wife will charge you $140. Hope you get the husband and not the wife… she doesn’t seem to pleasant

Cibele Gonçalves
Cibele Gonçalves Feb 2026
lovevine Freeman
lovevine Freeman Jan 2026

Excellent

Aj H
Aj H Nov 2025

It serves its purpose

Sal Verdi
Sal Verdi Aug 2025

Clean rooms

Kurtuluş Demir
Kurtuluş Demir Jul 2025

Write a Review

Share your experience to help other LGBTQ+ travelers

Log in to write a review

Your experiences help the community find great LGBTQ+ spaces.

Log in to review

Last updated on 5 August 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more