Pines Pavilion / Blue Whale Bars & Clubs in Fire Island – GayOut Guide
Gay Bars & Clubs ⭐ Featured LGBTQ+ Friendly

Pines Pavilion / Blue Whale

GayOut (34) 3.7
Google (47) 4.0
Tripadvisor See reviews ↓
What reviewers say

Visitors praise the delicious food, great service, and live music, particularly piano and blues nights. However, some complain about loud music making conversation difficult and one reviewer felt overcharged for drinks. The venue is noted to have a predominantly gay crowd, and while some found it welcoming, one visitor experienced negative comments.

77
/ 100
GayOut Score
3.7 G4.0
✅ Link copied!
Address
Fire Island Pines, Fire Island, NY 11782
📞
Phone
+1 631-597-6131
💰
Price Range
$$
🟢
Be the first to check in
Real-time community presence
No live tips yet — share what's happening here right now.

Hotels near Pines Pavilion / Blue Whale

via Stay22
Hotels near Pines Pavilion / Blue Whale
Loading map…

About this place Pines Pavilion / Blue Whale

The Pines Pavilion complex at the Fire Island Pines harbour is the social hub of the most prestigious gay summer community on the East Coast — a bar, restaurant, and event space built over the harbour water, with views across the Great South Bay toward the Long Island mainland. The Blue Whale bar is the anchor: a large outdoor bar in the harbour building where the crowd assembles from late afternoon onward on summer weekends, watching the water taxis come and go, recognising friends from the previous weekend, and performing the specific social ritual of the Fire Island Pines summer. The weekend tea dance at the Pines Pavilion is the Pines equivalent of Provincetown's Boatslip — a ritual afternoon gathering that has been running for decades and that constitutes the social centrepiece of the Pines weekend. The circuit party events held at the Pavilion throughout the summer season are among the most attended and most sought-after in the New York area. The harbour setting gives every event at the Pines Pavilion a visual backdrop that no mainland club can match: the boats, the water, the dunes behind the community, the light of the late afternoon on the bay.

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday 16:00-04:00
Saturday 14:00-04:00
Sunday 14:00-22:00

Features

Gay Ages 21-30 Ages 31-40 Happy Hour Live music Food served Outdoor Patio Party Club Piano Bar

Insider Tips

No tips yet — be the first to share a local secret!

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
4.0
47 reviews

Based on 47 Google reviews.

L A
L A May 2026

Love the piano night here is phenomenal!

argenisleonelf
argenisleonelf May 2026
Alex V
Alex V Sep 2025

This is an amazing piece! Delicious food and great service! We enjoyed our experience and will be back!

Isaac Namdar
Isaac Namdar Aug 2025
Carl Monroe
Carl Monroe Aug 2025

Surprised how nice yet crowded. As predicted, tide for low tea comes in around 6 and leaves at 8. Old people schedule but for the very young. Look for blond bartender, lovely southern.

DStyle Hair Couture
DStyle Hair Couture Aug 2025

Tuna tartare

Michael Claya
Michael Claya Aug 2025

The bartender swore up and down he sold me a double vodka mixer at tea. It didn't even taste like a single. "You only need one drink," he said. All to the tune of $60. Can you say ripoff? No wonder the crowd at tea is light.

TripAdvisor

Powered by TripAdvisor

Write a Review

Share your experience to help other LGBTQ+ travelers

Log in to write a review

Your experiences help the community find great LGBTQ+ spaces.

Log in to review

Last updated on 3 August 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more