Alexander's Guesthouse – Adults 21+, gay-friendly hotel in Old Town, Key West
GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at Alexander's Guesthouse – Adults 21+
Check availability and book your room.
🚶 16 min walk to Bobby's Monkey Bar · 5 / 1 km
Book a Room Now
Gay-Friendly Hotels Verified by GayOut

Alexander's Guesthouse – Adults 21+

Google (304) 4.9
Tripadvisor (1457) 4.9
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
What reviewers say

Visitors frequently praise the friendly and professional staff, the well-maintained and aesthetically pleasing property, and the relaxing atmosphere. However, one guest reported a significant issue regarding payment and the subsequent handling of their belongings.

98
/ 100
GayOut Score
G4.9 🦉4.9
✅ Link copied!
Address
1118 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040, USA
📞
Phone
(305) 294-9919
🌐
Website
alexanderskeywest.com

Hotels near Alexander's Guesthouse – Adults 21+

via Stay22
Hotels near Alexander's Guesthouse – Adults 21+
Loading map…

6 gay bars, clubs & saunas from our guide Purple outline = where the gay scene is concentrated

About this place Alexander's Guesthouse – Adults 21+

Alexander's Guest House, a long‑standing gay‑friendly inn on Fleming Street, sits behind a garden with a pool and hot tub. The property is a cluster of conch‑style houses spread around a modest courtyard. Each unit opens onto the garden, and the shared pool and hot tub are right there, making a quick dip easy after a day in the sun. Its clientele has been predominantly gay and lesbian for years, and the reviews read like a chorus of “highly recommend.” Guests repeatedly mention the relaxed vibe and the sense of community that the scattered houses create. Duval Street and the gay bars at its upper end are only a few blocks away, so you can walk to the nightlife without a car. Rates jump in the winter high season and spike around Fantasy Fest in October and Key West Pride in June, so book early if you want a room for those events.

Features

Mixed LGBTQ+ Year-round Gay-popular Adults only Pool Free breakfast

Insider Tips

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
4.9
★★★★★
304 reviews

Based on 304 Google reviews.

Gina Yancey Jun 2026
★★★★★

I am currently staying here and oh my gosh this place unbelievable. I stay in hotels all over Florida because of my job and this place is just absolutely amazing. Everything from the impeccable decor and detailed aesthetics down to the amazing staff. I can’t even say enough about it. The pool area is just pristine and the guests are all so friendly. And the rooms are adorable. I come to Key West once or twice a year and I will never stay anywhere else.

Durante Verzola Jun 2026
★★★★★

Had a beautiful stay at Alexander’s Guesthouse. My partner and I booked a one night stay and were pleasantly surprised to be given an upgrade on our room upon check in—free of charge! Our room was very clean, quiet, and comfortable. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. I asked if we could hang out by the pool after checking out, and the staff was extra accommodating. We were both wishing we didn’t have to leave! We had an amazing, relaxing time and will definitely be back!

Peter Baron-Krieger Jun 2026
★★★★☆
Red May 2026
★★★★★

Staff are the highlight of the property. All were professional and truly nice/friendly. Property is very well cared for; rooms pretty and functional; happy hour and breakfast are basic but good and well run.

Giuliano May 2026
★☆☆☆☆

I would like to formally document what happened at Alexander’s Guesthouse in Key West. There was an issue regarding payment for the last two nights of my stay. I asked if it was possible to cancel those nights, and I was told no. I was then informed that until payment was made, all of my luggage and personal belongings — including my identification and important documents — would be withheld. I was not even given the opportunity to return to the room to retrieve my essentials, and I was effectively left outside in pajamas, without access to my wallet, documents, or any practical way to resolve the payment immediately from my phone. At no point did I refuse to pay or avoid resolving the situation. I was honest, transparent, and trying to cooperate in good faith, expecting the same level of cooperation in return. Instead, I felt treated with suspicion and hostility throughout the entire situation. The staff member working at the front desk — who appeared to possibly be the owner — behaved in a way that felt extremely unprofessional and uncomfortable. Despite the extreme heat outside, she repeatedly came outside under the pretext of “checking the bicycles,” specifically in the exact area where I was standing, in a way that felt more like monitoring or intimidation than normal staff behavior. I understand hotels have policies regarding unpaid balances, but the way this situation was handled was deeply humiliating, distressing, and lacking basic human understanding.

sara wagganer May 2026
★★★★★

This is an excellent property for those of us who enjoy a little quiet time during the day (or night). I have been to 4 different properties in Key West, and I will 100% be back. It is difficult to search through all the listings to decide on a spot, so I will share my criteria that made Alexander's Guesthouse my top choice. King size bed, en suite bathroom, pool on property, and adult exclusive. This property is very well kept and everyone I encountered (including guests) were so welcoming. We walked or biked around with no issues! I hadn't ridden a bike in a decade and it's true, you dont forget! Breakfast was great, checkout was smooth, and the area was relaxed.

Latinas Beauty spa Apr 2026
★★★★★

TripAdvisor

Powered by TripAdvisor

Write a Review

20 reviews so far — add yours

Last updated on 17 November 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more