Island House Key West Hotels in Key West – GayOut Guide Gay Hotel — Men Only
Stay at Island House Key West
Check availability and book your room.
Book a Room Now
Gay Hotels ⭐ Featured LGBTQ+ Friendly

Island House Key West

Google (794) 4.7
Tripadvisor (734) 4.6
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
What reviewers say

Visitors frequently praise Island House for its outstanding service, excellent food and drinks, and welcoming atmosphere that fosters new friendships. However, one guest reported a negative experience with a disrespectful front desk staff member.

93
/ 100
GayOut Score
G4.7 🦉4.6
✅ Link copied!
Address
1129 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040
📞
Phone
+1 305-294-6284
🌐
Website
islandhousekeywest.com
💰
Price Range
$$$$

Hotels near Island House Key West

via Stay22
Hotels near Island House Key West
Loading map…

About this place Island House Key West

Island House is the most complete all-male resort in Key West — a self-contained gay men's destination on Fleming Street that operates as both a hotel and a social club, with facilities that make it unnecessary to leave the property if you prefer not to. The clothing-optional pool is the social centre of the complex; the jacuzzi, sauna, and gym are additional amenities that distinguish Island House from the island's gay guesthouses. The café serves breakfast and poolside food and drink throughout the day. The clientele is the full range of gay male visitors to Key West — couples, groups of friends, solo travellers — who prefer the company of an exclusively male environment and the freedom that clothing-optional status provides. The Fleming Street location is one block from Duval, giving the resort immediate access to the nightlife strip while providing enough separation for the resort to have a distinct, quieter identity. Island House is consistently ranked among the top gay resorts in the United States by the publications and websites that cover gay travel. For gay male visitors to Key West who want the full resort experience in a dedicated environment, Island House is the correct choice.

Features

Gay Gay-friendly (straight venue) Happy Hour Naked required Food served Outdoor Patio Safe space Walk-ins welcome Gay (mostly men) Themed parties Outdoor terrace

Insider Tips

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
4.7
794 reviews

Based on 794 Google reviews.

Jesse Warkentin
Jesse Warkentin Jun 2026

I will forever love my times at IH. This place (celebrating 50 Years!) has been a cornerstone of my open and free gay life… the folks who run it, and the beautiful generous men who visit it, are one of a kind. Community. Joy. Freedom. Respect. FUN. They’re here. I’m grateful. Happy 50th!

Adam Billingsley
Adam Billingsley Jun 2026
gabriel ferrer
gabriel ferrer Jun 2026
Leo Sangalang
Leo Sangalang Jun 2026
Victor Medina
Victor Medina Jun 2026

Excellent place in Key West The hotel has been open for 50 years and it is getting better. The staff is amazing and willing to make you feel comfortable all the time.

JamesChristianIRL
JamesChristianIRL Jun 2026

It’s the Island house. What else can you say?

Victor Medina
Victor Medina Jun 2026

Excellent place in Key West The hotel has been open for 50 years and it is getting better. The staff is amazing and willing to make you feel comfortable all the time.

TripAdvisor

Powered by TripAdvisor

Write a Review

Join 20 travelers who shared their experience here

Last updated on 18 September 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more