The Canteen Gay-Friendly Restaurants in Fire Island – GayOut Guide
restaurants Vérifié par GayOut

The Canteen

Google (98) 3.2
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
64
/ 100
Score GayOut
G3.2
✅ Lien copié !
Adresse
Harbor Walk, Fire Island Pines, NY 11782

Hôtels près de The Canteen

via Stay22
Hôtels près de The Canteen
Loading map…

À propos de ce lieu The Canteen

The Canteen is a casual food-and-drink counter on the harbor walk in Fire Island Pines, the gay resort community on the barrier island off Long Island. It sits among the waterfront businesses near the ferry landing, so it gets used as a quick stop for a bite or a drink between the beach, the boat and the evening bars. Like everything in the Pines it runs on a seasonal calendar and is busiest on summer weekends. Google reviews are mixed (3.2 from about 100 ratings), so treat it as a convenient option rather than a destination, and check whether it's open before planning around it outside peak season.

Caractéristiques

Gay Restauration sur place Gay (majorité d\'hommes) Mixte LGBTQ+ Décontracté / Chill Dansant Touristique Terrasse extérieure Lieu de jour Lieu de soirée Saisonnier (été seulement)

Conseils d\'initié

Avis de la communauté

Rédiger un avis

Avis Google

Vérifié par Google
3.2
★★★☆☆
98 avis

Basé sur 98 avis Google.

Cam DenUyl
Cam DenUyl Aug 2026
★★★★★
Arnab Majumdar
Arnab Majumdar Aug 2026
★★★☆☆
Felipe Ol
Felipe Ol Aug 2026
★★☆☆☆

Overpriced quality is not good better buy your own food .

Olivier DUHARD
Olivier DUHARD Jul 2026
★☆☆☆☆

No no no.

Martyn Boddy
Martyn Boddy Jul 2026
★★☆☆☆

Well, the food takes AGES and isn’t great. Also the bathrooms are duck taped shut which is just kind of weird? Honestly, if you’re in a hurry just go get a slice of pizza. Like a monet. Cute from a distance, a mess up close.

connorado9
connorado9 Jun 2026
★★★★★
Christopher Chung
Christopher Chung Jun 2026
★★★★★

Casual eatery perfectly situated within steps of Fire Island Pines ferry terminal. Smoked Salmon Bagel (though the bagel could have been crispier) was excellent, generously smeared and topped with micro-greens and the cutest miniature pickled peppers. Ample indoor and outdoor patio seating. Friendly counter staff.

Rédiger un avis

20 reviews so far — add yours

Last updated on 16 octobre 2026

Restez informé

Recevez les derniers événements LGBTQ+ et nouvelles ouvertures directement dans votre boîte mail.

Entrez votre e-mail pour recevoir les actualités Pride et alertes nouveaux lieux.

Déjà abonné ? Se désabonner

Vos choix en matière de confidentialité. Nous utilisons des cookies pour faire fonctionner GayOut et, avec votre consentement, mesurer son utilisation. En savoir plus ↗