Sinners & Saints Bars & Clubs in Indianapolis – GayOut Guide
Gay Bars & Clubs Verified by GayOut

Sinners & Saints

Google (284) 4.7
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
What reviewers say

Visitors frequently praise the Shelby Street Tavern as a cool, friendly neighborhood dive bar with a welcoming atmosphere, especially for queer patrons, and highlight great karaoke and trivia nights. However, some reviewers found the food to be inconsistent, with one specific complaint about the chicken and waffles.

94
/ 100
GayOut Score
G4.7
✅ Link copied!
Address
2849 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA
📞
Phone
+1 317-875-1932

Hotels near Sinners & Saints

via Stay22
Hotels near Sinners & Saints
Loading map…

About this place Sinners & Saints

Sinners & Saints is a queer bar at 2849 Shelby Street, south of Fountain Square by Garfield Park, in the space Google used to list as Shelby Street Tavern. Its Instagram calls it a queer bar and a sister to Sinners & Saints in Washington, DC, and its Google profile marks it as LGBTQ+-owned. The Indy Gay Agenda's 2026 bar guide counts it among the city's newer queer spaces. Expect a neighborhood bar with karaoke, trivia, games and live performances, plus outdoor seating. Google lists 4pm to 11pm Monday, Wednesday and Thursday, until 1am Friday and 2am Saturday, and noon to 7pm Sunday; it is closed on Tuesday. Check Instagram for the week's events.

Opening Hours

Open Now · closes 23:00
Monday 16:00-23:00
Tuesday closed
Wednesday 16:00-23:00
Thursday 16:00-23:00
Friday 16:00-01:00
Saturday 16:00-02:00
Sunday 12:00-19:00

Features

LGBTQ+ Karaoke Mixed LGBTQ+ Local favorite Pub Quiz nights Outdoor terrace Evening venue

Insider Tips

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
4.7
★★★★★
284 reviews

Based on 284 Google reviews.

S L
S L Jul 2026
★★★★★

Local pub 🍺

Heather Zimmerman
Heather Zimmerman Jul 2026
★★★★★
C G Smith
C G Smith Jun 2026
★★★★★

EDIT: The organization has rightfully asked me to clarify that I am not a member, voting or otherwise, past or present, of CCL, nor have I pursued membership or been interested in doing so. I’ve helped a little bit with a few of their events, but I’m just some concerned queer who got livid when he heard about this, and I thought that implying I’m with a group would make my words carry more weight. Stupid, and I make exactly one apology to y’all: for lying about my affiliation, I’m sorry. The organization has also asked me not to abut this reply, and I have grudgingly agreed. However, the post stays. I will notate my deception, and will also remove the needlessly rude section at the end, but the rest stands. ORIGINAL POST, EDITED AS EXPLAINED ABOVE: This is honestly a great bar, mostly, hence the 5-stars for Food, Service, and Atmosphere. I was initially glad my organization [NOTE: THIS IS A LIE, SEE ABOVE] chose to patronize this place. But that appreciation ended last night when bar management decided that keeping things quiet was more important than dealing with an assault and battery that happened at the bar. If the genders and races in the situation had been reversed, my friend would still be in jail right now, while the harasser in this situation got to finish out their night feeling good about getting away with what they've done. Someone reserving your bar for an event does not magically get the right to assault and batter someone. Never mind that the person doing the A&B has a history of harassing the person they chased out of the bar... [NOTE: FINAL PARAGRAPH REMOVED FOR BEING UNNECESSARILY RUDE]

_ Brawley
_ Brawley Jun 2026
★★★★★

Literally the coolest place on Earth. The owner is super duper nice. Made me feel super safe as a queer person to be here with my friends!

Nicholas Brown
Nicholas Brown Jun 2026
★★★★★

Cute spot!

Nicole E (HolyFNColey)
Nicole E (HolyFNColey) Jun 2026
★★★★★

Loved the bingo brunch !!!

Richard Napier
Richard Napier Jun 2026
★★★★★

First time. Food needs some work. But for bar food its good. The chicken and waffles would be great if the chicken was not whatever they served me yesterday. Pieces of quarter inch dried out burned on one side deep fried then placed on a flat top? Idk. But the Buffalo blackened Bleu burger was outstanding. The karaoke was fantastic the games on the patio would have been great. But the piles of fresh dog shit covered with poop bags was absolutely absurd. This place is amazing but there were things that could have been so much better. Simple things

Write a Review

20 reviews so far — add yours

Last updated on 5 November 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more