The Edgewater Hotel
Many guests praise The Edgewater for its elegant atmosphere, comfortable accommodations, and excellent lakefront location, with some highlighting exceptional service. However, a significant complaint is that the quality of service and rooms does not justify the cost, with one reviewer also mentioning inappropriate management behavior.
Hotels near The Edgewater Hotel
via Stay22About this place The Edgewater Hotel
Insider Tips
No tips yet — be the first to share a local secret!
Community Reviews
Write a ReviewGoogle Reviews
Verified by GoogleBased on 2,685 Google reviews.
Very upscale
Staff don’t have accountability.
Great hotel on Lake Mendota. We were able to grab an upgrade on a patio first floor, just feet from the shore line. Great sunsets!front desk also granted us a complementary 1 pm checkout. Service was outstanding. Also shoutout to the vault guy, Jason. Rooms were spacious and used great materials. My only complaint is the AC was a bit musty but other than that will definitely come back.
Long wait time to get seated but service and food were good
Luxurious and beautiful. Right in the shore of Lake Mendota, the Edgewater places you in a serene setting just minutes away from the Wisconsin state capitol building and the world-class University of Wisconsin Madison. Interesting architecture and history. Comfortable beds and clean rooms. Couldn't ask for more.
Write a Review
Share your experience to help other LGBTQ+ travelers
Log in to write a review
Your experiences help the community find great LGBTQ+ spaces.
Log in to reviewSuggest an Edit — The Edgewater Hotel
Last updated on 8 August 2026