Best Gay-Friendly Hotels in Montauk

Surfside Inn

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.6 (90)

Surfside Inn

Gay-Friendly Hotel

The inn offers a restaurant. Guests can enjoy a complimentary breakfast each morning. Wireless Internet access is complimentary. Onsite self parking is complimentary.

gay-friendly free-breakfast

LGBTQ+ Friendly

Ocean Resort Inn

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.5 (122)

Ocean Resort Inn

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Beachfront guesthouse offering homey rooms, suites & studios with Wi-Fi, plus an outdoor pool.

gay-friendly card-payments

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

Aqualina Inn Montauk

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.7 (123)

Aqualina Inn Montauk

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Casual hotel near the beach featuring an outdoor heated pool, picnic benches & bike storage.

gay-friendly hotel-pool

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

Breakers Montauk

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.2 (144)

Breakers Montauk

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Simple rooms & suites, all with ocean views, in a relaxed hotel featuring an outdoor pool.

gay-friendly hotel-pool

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

Kenny's Tipperary Inn

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.4 (561)

Kenny's Tipperary Inn

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Modest property offering homey quarters, some with kitchenettes, plus a seasonal pool & a garden.

gay-friendly hotel-pool

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

Royal Atlantic Beach Resort South

Gay-Friendly Hotel 3.9 (540)

Royal Atlantic Beach Resort South

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Simple lodging offering rooms & suites with patios, plus 2 pools & complimentary breakfast.

gay-friendly hotel-pool

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

Montauk Blue Hotel

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.3 (399)

Montauk Blue Hotel

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Experience a welcoming stay at Montauk Blue Hotel, an LGBTQ+ friendly hotel in beautiful Montauk, NY.

gay-friendly reservations

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

The Montauk Soundview

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.2 (140)

The Montauk Soundview

Gay-Friendly Hotel

An LGBTQ+ friendly hotel in Montauk, NY, offering a welcoming stay with beautiful waterfront views.

gay-friendly card-payments

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

RUSCHMEYERS

Gay-Friendly Hotel 3.7 (269)

RUSCHMEYERS

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Experience welcoming vibes at Ruschmeyer's in Montauk, a fantastic LGBTQ+ friendly haven for your getaway.

gay-friendly card-payments

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

The Surf Lodge

Gay-Friendly Hotel 3.5 (583)

The Surf Lodge

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Experience a welcoming stay at The Surf Lodge in Montauk, a LGBTQ+ friendly hotel offering a relaxed beach vibe.

gay-friendly beach-access

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Gay-Friendly Hotel 4.1 (1691)

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Gay-Friendly Hotel

Experience a welcoming stay at Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, an LGBTQ+ friendly destination in Montauk.

gay-friendly spa

LGBTQ+ Friendly Jun 2026