The Surf Lodge, gay-friendly hotel in Montauk
GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at The Surf Lodge
Check availability and book your room.
Book a Room Now
Gay-Friendly Hotels LGBTQ+ Friendly

The Surf Lodge

Google (583) 3.5
Tripadvisor (222) 3.8
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
What reviewers say

Visitors frequently praise the Surf Lodge's beautiful renovated rooms, delicious food, and the exceptional hospitality from staff like Manolo and Lucas. The live music is also a significant draw, creating a fun atmosphere. However, one reviewer mentioned that the place can be peaceful during the day and super fun at night, suggesting a potential for noise.

73
/ 100
GayOut Score
G3.5 🦉3.8
✅ Link copied!
Address
183 Edgemere St, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
📞
Phone
(631) 483-5045
🌐
Website
thesurflodge.com

Hotels near The Surf Lodge

via Stay22
Hotels near The Surf Lodge
Loading map…

About this place The Surf Lodge

The Surf Lodge is a boutique hotel on Fort Pond in Montauk, at the eastern tip of Long Island. It is better known for its summer scene than its rooms: the deck restaurant and bar draw big Hamptons crowds, and it runs a summer live-music series on the waterfront. It is a mainstream venue that welcomes gay guests, not a gay hotel. Google rates it 3.5 from about 583 reviews, with complaints mostly about prices, door policy and crowds. Rooms are few and expensive in July and August, and much of the operation is seasonal, so check what is open outside summer. The nearest gay scene is in the Hamptons and on Fire Island, a long drive west.

Features

Gay-friendly (straight venue) Card payments accepted Walk-ins welcome Reservation required WiFi Year-round Beach access Gay-friendly (straight venue)

Insider Tips

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
3.5
★★★★☆
583 reviews

Based on 583 Google reviews.

Susan Duffy Jun 2026
★★★★★
Sean Collier Jun 2026
★☆☆☆☆
James Cantelupe Jun 2026
★☆☆☆☆

Food was alright but resi was at 8 didn’t get our food til 930 took very long for someone to talk to us and just ignoring them someone was “walking us to our table” and just walked away so we had to go back to front and wait longer finally sat and ordered lobster that took 66 minutes on a wendsday would highly reccomend if you like mid lobster and waiting all day

jacob goldshtein Jun 2026
★★★☆☆

What is there to even say about this place that hasn’t already been said. Stuck in a pocket of time with former heavyweights like Tao, Sushi Samba and SoHo House the surf lodge is if anything authentic in its attempt to extract as much money as possible from the hordes of IG influencers, nepo babies and 30 something’s still clinging to their glory days. On one hand the food and restaurant experiance was genuinely decent, save the slightly excessive pricing. We got the steak, chicken, lobster pasta and the burrata salad which we weren’t disappointed with. On the other hand it’s literally a old motel that has convinced people to pay over 700 dollars for entry to a glorified margaritaville where d-list dj’s play house music and chicken tenders cost 150$. To hate on it is to give it attention which is to legitimize it. To conclude I respect surf lodge for the genius marketing and social engineering behind the project. Will I be back, probably…

Nicolina C Jun 2026
★☆☆☆☆

Memorial Day Weekend at The Surf Lodge was one of the most disappointing and uncomfortable experiences I've had in Montauk. What started as a simple question regarding the guest list somehow escalated into me being removed from the venue despite not being intoxicated, belligerent, disruptive, or causing any issues whatsoever. I remained calm and respectful, yet I was treated as though I had done something wrong. What made the situation even worse was being left outside alone in the cold rain for no apparent reason. As a woman, being put in that position made me feel incredibly unsafe and uncomfortable. No guest should be made to feel abandoned or vulnerable simply for asking a question. After sharing my experience, I was surprised to discover that many reviews describe similar issues involving rude staff, aggressive security, poor treatment of guests, and an overall culture of arrogance and exclusivity. Multiple online reviews mention hostile interactions with hosts, security personnel, and management, while others describe being denied entry or treated disrespectfully without explanation. (Tripadvisor) The venue may have the reputation of being a Montauk hotspot, but a beautiful location doesn't excuse poor treatment of guests. Customer service, professionalism, and basic respect should never be optional. Unfortunately, my experience lived up to the negative reputation that so many others have written about. I left feeling embarrassed, uncomfortable, and genuinely unsafe. I won't be returning, and I would encourage others to think carefully before spending their time and money here. At this point, I don't expect this review to change anything. Judging by the countless similar experiences shared by other guests over the years, this seems to be part of the culture rather than an isolated incident. Unfortunately, places that continue to prioritize exclusivity over basic respect rarely have any incentive to change. My review may not make a difference, but if it helps even one woman know what she might encounter before spending hundreds of dollars here, then it's worth writing. No one should have to worry about being dismissed, humiliated, or left standing alone outside in the cold and rain after simply asking a reasonable question as a result of egotistical and unfit doormen. Women deserve to feel safe, respected, and treated with dignity, regardless of who they are or whether they're on a guest list.

Nicola Radano May 2026
★★★★★
Ben EastwaterVlogs May 2026
★☆☆☆☆

Write a Review

20 reviews so far — add yours

Last updated on 19 November 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more