Wishing Well Guest House Hotels in New Hope – GayOut Guide
GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at Wishing Well Guest House
Check availability and book your room.
Book a Room Now
Gay Hotels LGBTQ+ Friendly

Wishing Well Guest House

Google (35) 4.6
Tripadvisor (119) 4.2
What reviewers say

Many visitors praise the Wishing Well Guest House for its charming character, welcoming hosts Michael and Scott, and delicious breakfasts. However, a significant complaint highlights serious cleanliness issues, with one reviewer describing the property as a health hazard with mold smells and dirty rooms.

88
/ 100
GayOut Score
G4.6 🦉4.2
✅ Link copied!
Address
144 Old York Road, New Hope
📞
Phone
215-862-8819
🌐
Website
wishingwellguesthouse.businesscatalyst.com
🟢
Be the first to check in
Real-time community presence
No live tips yet — share what's happening here right now.

Hotels near Wishing Well Guest House

via Stay22
Hotels near Wishing Well Guest House
Loading map…

About this place Wishing Well Guest House

The Wishing Well Guest House is a quiet place to stay in New Hope, Pennsylvania, one of the Northeast’s best LGBTQ+ towns.

This guesthouse feels like a comfortable home, mixing its history as a farm property with modern hospitality. You get the peaceful vibe of the countryside, but it’s still an easy walk to New Hope’s main drag.

From here, it’s a short stroll to all the shops, restaurants, and galleries. The backyard is a nice spot to unwind after you’ve had enough of the town’s bustle.

New Hope has been a go-to for LGBTQ+ travelers for ages, with plenty of places to eat, sleep, and hang out. The Wishing Well fits right in, focused on comfort and a friendly welcome. Check their website for room details, prices, and what’s available.

Insider Tips

No tips yet — be the first to share a local secret!

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
4.6
35 reviews

Based on 35 Google reviews.

Robin G
Robin G Nov 2023

Health hazard !!! This place is a health hazard !!! Not sure how they have managed to have a 4 star rating . The place has an extremely strong smell of mold and is absolutely filthy! Our room was complete with spider webs, dead bugs, live beetles and stink bugs ! Every surface was dingy and dirty! The shower head was frightening and we thought it best to wait until arriving at our next B&B ( which was immaculate thankfully) to take a shower. Do yourself a favor and go somewhere else!

Kelsey Ellis
Kelsey Ellis Jul 2023

Stayed here in October of last year and I am still thinking about it! Such an amazing experience with wonderful hosts and a comforting atmosphere. If I ever return to New Hope this is where I will be staying. I definitely recommend!

Elaine Carneavale
Elaine Carneavale Nov 2022

The Inn has character and charm. We loved the fire burning in the living room. Our room was not very clean and had several areas of disrepair. Our biggest concern was how cold our room was making sleep almost impossible. We slept in our clothes and a shower in the morning was out of the question. The bathroom floor felt like ice. Other guests also commented on how chilly their rooms were as well. Overall, disappointed with our stay.

P L.
P L. Oct 2022

My boyfriend and I stayed here last Friday night and the owners Michael and Scott were so kind and friendly. It was such a quaint ,unique house and so interesting to explore. I felt very comfortable here. The house has a nice energy to it. Thank you kindly to them both for having us. :)

Gerd Bileck
Gerd Bileck Jun 2022

Idyll.

Rebecca Huntting
Rebecca Huntting May 2022

Loved staying here for a night to get out of NYC. Michael and Scott are wonderful - set us up, gave us great recs for food in New Hope (which is a beautiful stroll away along a creek), and served up delicious breakfast in the morning. So much heart and warmth in this place. Highly recommend!

Meyver's Cleaning
Meyver's Cleaning Feb 2022

I would like to start by thanking Michael and Scott the owners of this beautiful bed and breakfast for such welcoming and outstanding service. Enjoyed the stayed so much the house it’s very quaint and Nicely decorated, Also need to comment on the Warm breakfast so delicious made me feel at Home. I highly suggest it.

TripAdvisor

Powered by TripAdvisor

Write a Review

Share your experience to help other LGBTQ+ travelers

Log in to write a review

Your experiences help the community find great LGBTQ+ spaces.

Log in to review

Last updated on 4 August 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more