Come As You Are Inn LLC, gay-friendly hotel in Fire Island
GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at Come As You Are Inn LLC
Check availability and book your room.
🚶 133 min walk to The Ice Palace
Book a Room Now
Gay-Friendly Hotels Verified by GayOut

Come As You Are Inn LLC

Google (81) 5.0
Tripadvisor (9) 5.0
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
What reviewers say

Visitors consistently praise the Come As You Are Inn for its welcoming and attentive hosts, Mark and Ari, who go above and beyond to make guests feel comfortable. Reviewers also highlight the delicious homemade breakfasts and the inn's clean, well-decorated, and peaceful accommodations. One reviewer mentioned looking forward to using the pool and backyard amenities in warmer weather, suggesting these might not be available year-round.

100
/ 100
GayOut Score
G5.0 🦉5.0
✅ Link copied!
Address
59 Greene Ave, Sayville, NY 11782, USA
📞
Phone
(917) 288-1272
🌐
Website
www.comeasyouareinn.com

Hotels near Come As You Are Inn LLC

via Stay22
Hotels near Come As You Are Inn LLC
Loading map…

5 gay bars, clubs & saunas from our guide

About this place Come As You Are Inn LLC

Come As You Are Inn is an LGBTQ-oriented guesthouse on Greene Avenue in Sayville, on the south shore of Long Island. Sayville is the mainland ferry town for Fire Island Pines and Cherry Grove, so the inn works as a base for people who want the beaches and tea dances by day without paying island prices or chasing a share house. The listing has a perfect 5.0 Google rating from around 80 reviews, which suggests a small, owner-run operation. Ferry schedules shrink sharply outside summer, so plan crossings before booking. Confirm room options and minimum stays on comeasyouareinn.com or by phone.

Features

Gay Lesbian / Women-focused LGBTQ+ LGBTQ+ owned Safe space Walk ins welcome Air conditioning Mixed LGBTQ+ Wheelchair accessible ♿ WiFi Seasonal (summer only) Free breakfast

Insider Tips

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
5.0
★★★★★
81 reviews

Based on 81 Google reviews.

Tashi Svenghuli May 2026
★★★★★

Marc and Ari and excellent hosts, super friendly! My fiancé and I had just come down for a wedding nearby. The room was clean and spacious, the bed and pillows were very comfy, plus our continental breakfast came with delicious homemade bread and jams/jellies. We'll definitely have to come again very soon!

Laura Iwazko May 2026
★★★★★

We stayed here for three nights and had a really great experience. The place was clean, comfortable, and very welcoming. The hosts were incredibly kind and helpful throughout our stay, and they made us feel at home from the moment we arrived. The homemade breakfast was absolutely delicious. We especially loved the fresh bread, homemade jam, and the small cakes and pastries, which were amazing every morning. You could really feel the care and attention put into everything. The atmosphere was calm and relaxing, and the location was perfect for exploring the area. We would definitely recommend this bed and breakfast to anyone looking for a warm, friendly, and authentic place to stay. Thank you again for your hospitality!

A Apr 2026
★★★★★

Great location for the nearby wedding venue/airport, the rooms are clean, spacious, and comfortable. The hosts are kind and diligent to their guests, and they gave my wife and I a ride to a nearby restaurant to meet up with our friends free of charge. The hosts also made excellent homemade freshly baked breads and muffins for breakfast. Overall, this is the best place in town for a real bed and breakfast experience.

Syed ali Fayzan Apr 2026
★★★★★

I had a wonderful stay at Come As You Are Inn LLC. It’s an LGBTQ-friendly place with a very warm and welcoming atmosphere. We stayed for one night (Saturday), and the location is super convenient—just a few minutes’ walk from the Sayville Train Station. The hosts were incredibly friendly and went above and beyond to make us feel comfortable. We really enjoyed chatting with them. The property itself is beautiful, with a licensed bar, a piano, and a relaxing backyard featuring a hot tub and saltwater pool (not open yet due to the weather). The room was quiet, clean, and had a very comfortable bed. The bathroom was huge and even included a washer and dryer. Breakfast was included and simple but nice—bread, cupcakes, coffee, and orange juice. You can also order a continental breakfast. The dining area was cozy and inviting. One thing that really stood out was the kindness of the hosts. We were running late to catch our ferry, and they kindly gave us coffee, orange juice, bread, and cupcakes to take with us. Overall, a lovely experience with thoughtful hosts. Highly recommended!

Chris V Apr 2026
★★★★★

Cute B&B right in the heart of Sayville! My dad and I loved staying at Come as you are inn! Beautiful location, clean rooms with elegant style and two wonderful hosts with so many fascinating stories! It’s a home away from home. Don’t miss Ari’s incredible breakfast with homemade baked goods and locally sourced jams! Could not recommend it more!

Chris Allen Jan 2026
★★★★★

Wonderful hosts, great conversation, helpful recommendations, lovely rooms, and amazing homemade breakfasts!

Suzanne Ishii Dec 2025
★★★★★

We recently spent 3 memorable nights at this inn. It is walkable to the quaint downtown with a cat cafe, post office, various shops, and LI railroad as well as a short drive to several parks, the Fire Island ferry, restaurants, and more. Hosts Mark and Ari have thought of everything to make the premises visitor friendly: their relaxing speakeasy where pianist Mark entertains guests, hot tub and pool in the well manicured back yard, ample continental breakfasts with hot entree options. We have been completed spoiled by the morning array of Ari's home made breads, popovers and more. Try the homemade jams and applesauce!

TripAdvisor

Powered by TripAdvisor

Write a Review

20 reviews so far — add yours

Last updated on 19 November 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more