Fire Island Beach House, gay-friendly hotel in Fire Island
GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at Fire Island Beach House
Check availability and book your room.
🚶 67 min walk to Cherry's On The Bay
Book a Room Now
Gay-Friendly Hotels LGBTQ+ Friendly

Fire Island Beach House

Google (196) 3.8
Tripadvisor (208) 3.5
Been here? Rate it in 3 clicks
What reviewers say

Some visitors praise the hotel's location and beautiful decor, with one mentioning great service and accommodating staff. However, many guests complain about the high prices not matching the quality of service and cleanliness, citing issues like stained linens, broken amenities, and rude staff. There are also concerning reports of pests and unhealthy conditions.

73
/ 100
GayOut Score
G3.8 🦉3.5
✅ Link copied!
Address
25 Cayuga St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770, USA
📞
Phone
(631) 583-8000
🌐
Website
www.thefibh.com

Hotels near Fire Island Beach House

via Stay22
Hotels near Fire Island Beach House
Loading map…

5 gay bars, clubs & saunas from our guide

About this place Fire Island Beach House

Fire Island Beach House is a seasonal hotel on Cayuga Street in Ocean Beach, Fire Island. It is a mainstream hotel listed as gay-friendly, not a gay hotel. Ocean Beach is the island's busiest mixed and mostly straight village, with bars, shops and ferry service from Bay Shore. Reviews are mixed (3.8 from about 200 Google ratings). The island's famous gay communities, Cherry Grove and Fire Island Pines, are several miles east, and there are no cars, so you get between villages by water taxi or a long beach walk. If gay nightlife is the reason for your trip, staying in the Pines or the Grove makes more sense. Check opening dates, as most Fire Island hotels close in winter.

Features

Gay-friendly (straight venue) LGBTQ+ Walk ins welcome Air conditioning WiFi Seasonal (summer only) Pool Beach access

Insider Tips

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
3.8
★★★★☆
196 reviews

Based on 196 Google reviews.

Carlos Cortes Apr 2026
★★★★★
Lacey Princess Feb 2026
★☆☆☆☆
Daphale Stonecress Feb 2026
★☆☆☆☆

Cheap hotel standards with high rates. I would not recommend. Staying here is actually a hazard to your health. No joke.

Chanda Amulya Feb 2026
★☆☆☆☆

If you like sleeping with roaches, spiders and black mold then this place is for you. If you like swimming in pools that are slimy, not cared for and crumbling, you'll love it here. If you enjoy bumping elbows with drunk degenerates who mosey on down for a dip without any repercussions as you're paying a couple K for an overpriced room, then don't wait on your next booking. The staff here is something else - they give zero care for any of your concerns. You might as well be camping. Especially since the hot water never really seems to work.

karyn hirsch Sep 2025
★★★☆☆

This is the most mixed up review ever. I stayed at FIBH - one of 2 wedding venues recommended in the wedding invitation The location is lovely with a minimalist room that was clean with comfortable beds When I booked, I noted one wedding bride cited how well they treated a guest with mobility issues which I have presently-torn knee and recently broken ankle. I explained to the person who booked me that I needed the least stairs for the room because I have a torn knee to be operated on in October and a recently broken ankle. The room was fine, minimalist (strangely no luggage racks, chair or table inside) but that's ok. The shower was nice and the beds wonderfully comfortable if you like soft. People with broken ankles and knees like soft! It is 3 star. The grounds have a picnic table and easy beach access. The astroturf is a little weird but who cares? The issue was that FiBH did not want to pick me up at the dock with luggage, told me that I could not go in the golf cart because someone sued them when they purposely fell out and could not help me make alternate arrangements. They were definitive that I should not ask in the future. Later, they would not let us even use a cart so my husband could pull me up the road. They claimed the tire was flat although it looked fine. Some of the very nice staff were terrified if they helped me that they would be fired. You might think they would have mentioned this issue at the time of booking so I could have made alternate arrangements with the wedding party ahead of time. Or just not been able to come. This eventuality had not occurred to me when I booked so I missed all the activities the first night which required going back to the dock (they refused to get me back there) and then water taxi to Ocean Beach to the Mermaid. It was mean-spirited and inflexible not even to suggest anything. Ironically, the heavy door to the bathroom had no emergency stop on the slide mechanism and so fell on the bed. If you stay thee, slide that door very slowly!Had we been on the bed, it would have crushed us. Now that is a lawsuit waiting to happen. LOL The following day I called the wedding venue (Flynns) who with the wedding planners kindly had me picked up and returned after the reception. They were surprised at FIBH. This is a problem with the owners and management. Some of the staff wanted to be helpful but were clear they would be fired. It is also a problem with character because there were some staff who just flat out decided it was not their problem. Know that management doesn't give a hoot if guests have these problems. It is sad I missed day1 of the festivities. After the first day, I managed to make arrangements to get places like to the wedding and then back to the dock to go home. It was surprising people turn their back on someone who needed assistance. Is this the new normal? FIBH needs to advertise they are not friendly to those with mobility issues. If someone is having a wedding with guests with mobility issues, they should know they will not be assisted but he hotel-kinda crazy for $500/night although they told me that was very cheap for them-usually it is $1000/night. It created unnecessary stress and was humiliating. FIBH-Just be clear- state on the website that those with mobility issues are not welcome and won't be accommodated. Or FIBH-go figure something else out like a little chain to go across the passenger side of the cart or a paper you could sign relieving FIBH of responsibility. Of course, then they might get sued under the ADA. Or just be human, not assaholic. I was glad I finally got to attend the lovely reception/wedding and many thanks to those who were sympathetic/helpful

Dora Chang Sep 2025
★★★☆☆

Overpriced. No coffee machine nor fridge. Charged extra $50 for pool we never used. But outside there are bikes that you have to pay to use. When asked how to get there, hotel staff didn’t even know the closest pier. We ended up having to walk more than necessary with our luggages.

Anan Revie Sep 2025
★☆☆☆☆

I probably would have had a better stay at a cheap motel. Worst hotel stay in my life and incredibly overpriced

TripAdvisor

Powered by TripAdvisor

Write a Review

20 reviews so far — add yours

Last updated on 17 November 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more