The Garden City Hotel Hotels in New York – GayOut Guide
GAY-FRIENDLY
Stay at The Garden City Hotel
Check availability and book your room.
Book a Room Now
Gay Hotels LGBTQ+ Friendly

The Garden City Hotel

GayOut (40) 3.7
Google (2206) 4.4
Tripadvisor See reviews ↓
What reviewers say

Many guests praise the friendly and welcoming staff, with some highlighting specific individuals and the overall good customer service. However, a significant number of visitors report issues with cleanliness, including dirty carpets, strong odors, and missing amenities like toilet paper and towels, with some describing the hotel as run-down.

80
/ 100
GayOut Score
3.7 G4.4
✅ Link copied!
Address
45 7th St, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
📞
Phone
(877) 549-0400
🌐
Website
www.gardencityhotel.com
🟢
Be the first to check in
Real-time community presence
No live tips yet — share what's happening here right now.

Hotels near The Garden City Hotel

via Stay22
Hotels near The Garden City Hotel
Loading map…

About this place The Garden City Hotel

The Garden City Hotel is a gay-friendly hotel located in Garden City, New York, providing accommodations for LGBTQ+ travelers visiting the area. Situated at 45 7th Street in Garden City, NY, the property welcomes queer guests looking for a comfortable and affirming place to stay. As a gay hotel, this venue is part of the hospitality landscape that caters specifically to LGBTQ+ travelers seeking welcoming spaces. Whether you're visiting Garden City for business, leisure, or to explore the surrounding Long Island area, a dedicated gay-friendly hotel offers the peace of mind of staying somewhere that celebrates and respects the LGBTQ+ community. For more information about amenities, room options, and current offerings, you can visit their website at gardencityhotel.com. This is a great option to consider when planning your trip to the Garden City area if you're looking for LGBTQ+-affirming lodging.

Features

Gay-friendly (straight venue) LGBTQ+

Insider Tips

No tips yet — be the first to share a local secret!

Community Reviews

Write a Review

Google Reviews

Verified by Google
4.4
2,206 reviews

Based on 2,206 Google reviews.

Lori Fogarsi
Lori Fogarsi Jun 2026

Beautiful hotel with top notch service. Everything went seamlessly and our room was exquisite. We enjoyed drinks at the outdoor bar in the evening, as well as the magnificent Sunday brunch at the Red Salt Room. Highly recommended.

Lucy Artiga-C
Lucy Artiga-C Jun 2026

This place is so bad, they didn’t have toilet paper, towels or shampoo in the room. The hotel was disgusting and it looks so torn down, you feel like you’re in a bad motel, not hotel. It’s so run down, they don’t care anymore that it stinks and carpets are dirty. Don’t book here, I’m warning you, you’ll regret it. This was the door to the bathroom, a big hole and a door that doesn’t close well.

Christine Thomas
Christine Thomas Jun 2026

When my husband and I booked this room we were very skeptical because of the reviews. However, we were pleasantly surprised by our stay. We did not experience any of the negative comments or things that people were saying. The only issue I had was the front desk lady had a little bit of an attitude when I was having trouble with my key, but it was nothing serious enough for me to be angry or hold a grudge. Another thing, they do require a $300 security deposit during your stay to ensure nothing is ruined, I completely understand that, and most places do require a security deposit but $300 did seem to be a lot and took us by surprise. I did not fight them on it, I paid it, and I got it within 2 business days back. However, for other people staying it seemed to be an issue. My husband and I were staying at the very first room by the front desk so we could hear people screaming and yelling about the $300, understandable. Going back to the comments about the housekeeping and location. Our room was very clean, the air conditioning was already on so we walked into a nice cool room. The sheets and and pillow cases were completely clean, our TV and mini fridge worked perfectly fine. Other than that incident with one of the front desk members, everyone else was very nice and welcoming. We did not notice any people standing outside the hotel making us feel unsafe. We even got back around 2am one night, no issues at all. Nobody tried to enter our room without permission, not even housekeeping, and nothing was stolen from us. We also did not smell any drugs or see any drug activity through our stay. We also enjoyed the location, it was very close to a lot. Target is just around the corner and because we were in town for a wedding, Uber rides were very cheap and fast or you could walk.

Jenny Conway
Jenny Conway Jun 2026

The entire GCH team was exceptionally attentive and responsive to every request and question throughout both the planning process and the events themselves. From the seamless transitions between venues to the outstanding food and beverage service, every detail was executed flawlessly. Most importantly, the bride and groom—and all of their guests—had an incredible time all weekend long. The experience truly exceeded all expectations.

Owen thompson
Owen thompson Jun 2026

The ambiance of the place is excellent However the restaurant on the first floor i was expecting more of a well rounded service from server it was not top notch The food was not what I expected the crab appetizer was ok ! The salmon dish was a waste my salmon was tasting Bitter like burnt the veg pok chow was swimming in a lot of sauce the mushroom was ok! . The manager did not come over to our table to see how things was going but I notice he went to ever other table . Chances of dining there again is slim.

Darren Bowden
Darren Bowden Jun 2026

The staff - at the hotel and restaurant - were remarkable. It was my wife’s birthday, and they went above and beyond for her (in a very elevated way). The room, food, and staff were exceptional. Bravo!

Stephanie Kooyenga
Stephanie Kooyenga Jun 2026

This is a beautiful hotel in a fantastic location. The staff is always attentive and friendly, and the rooms are consistently spotless, spacious, and comfortable. I highly recommend it and look forward to staying here again.

TripAdvisor

Powered by TripAdvisor

Write a Review

Share your experience to help other LGBTQ+ travelers

Log in to write a review

Your experiences help the community find great LGBTQ+ spaces.

Log in to review

Last updated on 5 August 2026

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest LGBTQ+ events and venue openings in your inbox.

Enter your email to receive Pride event updates and new-venue alerts.

Already a subscriber? Unsubscribe

Your privacy choices. We use cookies to run GayOut and, with your consent, measure usage. Learn more