The Tryst Fire Island

The Tryst Fire Island is the boutique hotel on the Fire Island Pines harbor, opened in 2025 on the site of the long-running Botel by Tryst Hospitality — the group that also reimagined the surrounding Pines waterfront venues. The roughly 30-room property puts guests in the middle of the Pines' harborfront scene, a few steps from the Blue Whale, the Pavilion, Sip-N-Twirl and the ferry dock. It is a seasonal, adults-oriented property geared to the island's overwhelmingly gay summer clientele. As a brand-new opening its online review history is still thin; details and rates are best confirmed directly with the property.